logo

Canister vs Upright

Submit to FacebookSubmit to Google PlusSubmit to StumbleuponSubmit to TwitterSubmit to LinkedIn
Canister vs Upright
Canister or Upright?


In this short article we take a look at the differences between the canister vacuum and the upright vacuum. Both configurations have been around for years and most people have one or the other – and sometimes both – at home. But if you are in the market for a new vacuum cleaner which style is the right one for you? There are advantages and disadvantages to each.  Even if you have a favorite brand, many manufacturers today make uprights as well as canisters.  We’ve also included some information highlighting the pros and cons of stick vacs and handhelds. 


Canister vs Upright
If you are looking for a vacuum cleaner to clean your house or large apartment, you are probably considering either an upright or a canister vacuum.  These are generally made for large area cleaning, but they are different in many respects.

LG LuV250C
LG LuV250C Upright

Uprights are slightly more popular than canister vacuums but canisters still sell very well.  Folks tend to prefer one configuration over another and this often comes down to what one is used to.

I suspect many of you grew up with one vacuum type or another in your household and you may have stuck with it – I did when I purchased my first vacuum (a canister).  But the best machine can also be dependent on the kind of cleaning and the needs of the vacuumer.  Considerations may include maneuverability, flooring, reach, etc. 

Generally speaking, when comparing the two styles of vacuum the following is often (but not always) true:

 UPRIGHT CANISTER
 Wider cleaning path Narrower cleaning path
 Better on carpet Better on bare floors
 More commonly has motorized brushbar Frequently have air-driven brushbar
 Longer power cord Shorter power cord
 With power cord and hose, longer reach Shorter reach
 In bagged units, often have larger bags In bagged units, often have smaller bags
 Rarely has automatic power cord rewind Often has automatic power cord rewind
 Harder to get around and under furniture Easier to get around and under furniture
 Have to move entire machine on each pass Only have to move hose & nozzle on each pass

Consider the above carefully before buying your next vacuum – it may help create a better cleaning experience.  It should be noted that manufacturers have attempted to overcome some of the shortcomings of each vacuum type with the addition of special features and tools.  Depending on the brand and model, this has had some level of success. 

Ergorapido Stick Vac
Ergorapido Stick Vac


Stick vs Handheld
Stick vacuums and handheld vacuums are sufficiently different that there is less confusion with respect to the best machine for the job.  However there is some overlap and we see both units used to clean up small messes on bare floors and sometimes carpet.  Both are also generally cordless and bagless (but not all).

The stick vacuum can handle medium sized jobs and is only used to clean the floor while the handheld is only for smaller jobs and can be used on the floor, tabletops, counters, car interiors, etc.  The handheld is clearly more versatile but it is not the right machine when a significant area is involved. 

Most stick vacs are capable on bare floors but only some are able to do a decent job on carpet (they need a brushbar that works well for this).  The stick vacuum is best suited for cleaning medium sized areas – smaller than a large apartment or house - and can be a handy alternative to bringing out the canister or upright.  They are usually cordless and lightweight so they are easy to lift and maneuver and you don’t have to worry about finding an outlet. 

Dirt Devil AccuCharge
Dirt Devil AccuCharge

Handhelds rarely have a brushbar and are not made for any kind of medium or large area cleaning.  They are used on almost all surfaces however – for quick pickups of dry messes or spills.  You commonly find these in a workshop or a kitchen.

Some manufacturers have tried to bridge the gap between the handheld and the stick vac by adding separable handheld units to their stick vac – examples are the Electrolux Ergorapido and the Shark Navigator Freestyle.  This approach has worked rather well and if you require both a stick and handheld these machines are fairly effective.

Stick vacuums and handheld vacuums often have the following differences:

 STICK HANDHELD
 Medium and small area cleaning Small area cleaning
 Can be better on carpet if have brushbar Rarely have brushbar
 Only for cleaning floors Can clean floors, car interiors, countertops, etc
 Lightweight Usually even lighter
 Some models include handheld Only handheld



Nigel RusscoNigel Russco has been writing for Vacuum Cleaner Advisor for years and has a background in business and engineering, as well as a keen interest in anything related to vacuum cleaners. Connect with Nigel on Google+





POST YOUR COMMENTS

Submit to FacebookSubmit to Google PlusSubmit to StumbleuponSubmit to TwitterSubmit to LinkedIn

Comments  

-1 # Tim T. 2015-05-12 11:02
There are so many options to choose from. My entire house has tile floors. I think a cannister is the best option. What do you recommend under $300 ? Should I consider a reconditioned Miele that\'s under $200 ?
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote

Add comment


Security code
Refresh

 
Search

Vacuum Cleaner Finder

Find the best vacuum cleaners fast! Use the Vacuum Cleaner Finder! It helps you quickly weed out the underperformers and shows you the top rated machines.


About Me

Hello!

I'm Nigel Russco, a 50 year old professional engineer originally from the west coast of Canada.  I love to review vacuums and I’ve been doing just that since 2008.  

I make every effort to write unbiased, intelligent vacuum cleaner reviews and I provide average consumer ratings for each and every vacuum cleaner I investigate.  My ultimate goal is to ensure you find the best vacuum for your cleaning needs.  

I also like to help when I can so feel free to send comments.


August 2017 VACUUM DEALS

Deep discounts on best-selling vacuum cleaners from Amazon - a reputable vendor with a tremendous range of brands and models. 

 

Who's Online

We have 115 guests online.


         VACUUM HELP CORNER

See our Vacuum Cleaner Ratings Table. It provides avg consumer ratings for ALL reviewed vacuums.

Vacuum won't turn on? No suction? Belt broke? See our comprehensive list of handy vacuum repair tips.

Should you buy a bagless or bagged vacuum?  Find out by reading Bagged or Bagless Vacuum?.

Which is better? A canister vacuum or an upright vacuum? Read Canister vs Upright.

Learn more about vacuum technology, allergen filters, carpet types, etc. See our Helpful Vacuum Websites List.

What is HEPA filtration? Do you need it? Read our HEPA filters article.

View our latest Vacuum Videos, and see top 10 upright and canister videos.

Got a Hoover Steam Vacuum? We have Hoover Steamvac Manuals.

See vacuum collector interviews and helpful infographics.


Follow Me on Pinterest

Who makes the best Vacuum Cleaners?